Is it stereotypical for a black character to have HIV/AIDS?

8

8 Answers

PJ Stein Profile
PJ Stein answered

Not that I am aware of. In fact I can't think of any.

Tris Fray Potter Profile

I can't think of any characters from any ethnicity with HIV/AIDS

Tom  Jackson Profile
Tom Jackson answered

Are you asking if it would be stereotypical to create such a character or whether such characters generally exist with that ethnicity and those issues?

Certain it would be appropriate to create such a character since you are a "novelist in training" if the context benefited from it or it were essential part of your writing.

I know nothing about how frequently such characters might currently exist in current dramatis personae.

2 People thanked the writer.
View all 7 Comments
N. Harmonik
N. Harmonik commented
Oh thanks!
Tom  Jackson
Tom Jackson commented
In order to message someone directly on this site, you have to be following each other.

"Following"on this site has nothing do with some kind of followers "score."

If someone follows me, I always follow them back as a courtesy---in case they do want to send me a brief comment or message that they don't want public.

Of the 39 people I follow, I have only communicated directly with I think 3 of them in the past year---and they are the only ones I communicate with privately.

And "private" simply means I know I can make sure they become aware of something I want them to be aware of---something they may no see while scanning the questions.

(I'm assuming you are relatively new, so I'm just giving you some information you might find useful.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Thanks for the message, Tom. I'm aboard.
Nicholas Bartsch Profile

Personally I feel that this has been a stereotype that has died off awhile ago. First off The reason this stereotype was so common was due to the fact awhile back scientists had made conclusive evidence  that HIV/Aids,along with other STD's had originated from certain colonies in Southern Africa

  They believed that the first carriers of the disease were the chimpanzees that had been living their,that was then passed down by their great ancestors.However the reason that this stereotype is starting to dissolve is because scientists are discovering areas all around the globe that could have been the home of the first carriers of HIV/AIDS. The fact of the matter is we need to stop blaming each other  for diseases we spread.

3 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Back in the 16th century when syphilis first made its appearance (coincidentally or not, following the early journeys to the new world) the British claimed that it had originated when a French princess copulated with an ape. The Brits didn't like the French very much. Many of them still don't. >:-/
Didge Doo Profile
Didge Doo answered

I saw this question yesterday and kept right away from it. If I read it correctly it has the whiff of racism and, yeah, it smacks of stereotyping. Because I live on the far side of the Pacific I can't know from personal experience to what extent such a characterisation would have in the US. Unless it's carefully handled it could generate all the wrong kinds of reaction.

From a writer's point of view ANY character can have ANY ailment or any quality. In order for a book to be entertaining it needs protagonists and antagonists, it's the struggle that grips the reader.
It's as racist to promote one group -- say Blacks -- as completely pure and noble while all the bad guys are White; so your character can have any malady or moral defect but you need to be careful with the balance. Avoid stereotyping.

Virginia Lou Profile
Virginia Lou answered

Dear N. Harmonik,

Your Q is interesting from the perspective that around 1990, HIV/AIDS was used to justify homophobia...HIV a death sentence then... then several movies were made depicting young gay men dealing with AIDS, coming out to their families...and dying. Such media truly helped with advocacy for the gay experience.

* * *

So I would say, just use all your writing skill and your wisdom to make certain your black character is done well, diminishing rather than reinforcing any stereotypes.

For reference, a couple of impressive movies from the early years of HIV/AIDS are AN EARLY FROST, beautifully acted by Aidan Quinn, and LONGTIME COMPANION.

Answer Question

Anonymous