Is White Meat Healthier Than Red Meat?

3

3 Answers

lakeesha Hennessy Williams Profile
My feeling is that both types of meat have pros and cons. Also the way a meat is prepared has a lot to do with how healthy (or unhealthy) it is to consume.

Is white meat healthier than red meat?
As someone who has battled with weight issues for a while, the question of white meat vs red meat is nothing new to me.

I'd often been told that white meat was healthier than red meat, and as someone who loves her rib-eye steaks and pork ribs, I had to get to the bottom of this.

The first problem I encountered was that there is no exact definition of what the terms 'white' and 'red' mean in terms of meat.

Yes, we all know that chicken is white meat and lamb is red meat- but where does goose or venison lie?

The second problem I found was that, for every pro I could find, there was always another con to balance it out:

The difference between white and red meat

White meat is usually considered the healthier of the meat options.

This is because most white meat is:

  • Lean
  • Has less calories
  • Has a lower fat content
This all sounds like good news, but the truth is that the differences in calorie and fat content are actually not that big.
And if you think about dishes like fried chicken (yum) then you're throwing the fat and calorie count out of the window.

Red meat gets a bit of a bad rap nowadays. It's often linked to words like 'cancer' or 'high fat'.

People often forget to mention that it is a good source of protein, vitamins, nutrients and anti-oxidants.

My view is that it is possible to live a healthy lifestyle eating both types of meat in moderation.
Zeke Zepplin Profile
Zeke Zepplin answered
The answer to this question would really be no. It really all depends on how you prepare the meat.
Anything fried can be unhealthy for any person. Any meat that is cooked, baked or broiled is usually a lot healthier. So, it is really all a matter of opinion...there is no scientific proof that one is healthier than the other.

There are many articles saying one is better, etc. Read for yourself and be the judge.

"Chicken and fish traditionally have been considered healthier than red meat because many cuts of red meat can have too much saturated fat," says Peter O. Kwiterovich, M.D., director of The Johns Hopkins University Lipid Clinic. "Now, lean cuts of red meat are readily available to consumers. If you follow a heart-healthy diet, it doesn't make a difference whether you eat red meat or white meat, as long as you choose lean cuts."

Kathy Castillo Profile
Kathy Castillo answered
For a start, there is no general agreement as to what is white meat and what is red meat.

Many people use this to distinguish between poultry and pork, beef or lamb. But a goose drumstick is much "redder" than a pale piece of veal. Analysis of the contents also provides no indication that a turkey burger is better than one made of beef.

North American studies, in which "red" meat did poorly, probably did not take into account that many cuts of pork and beef are treated with nitrite salts and subsequently grilled, and that is what is unhealthy.

No, the answer to this question would really be no. It really all depends on how you prepare the meat. Anything fried can be unhealthy for any person. Any meat that is cooked, baked or broiled is usually a lot healthier. So, it is really all a matter of opinion...there is no scientific proof that one is healthier than the other.

Answer Question

Anonymous